30 Comments
User's avatar
Men of the West's avatar

Such helpful work, brother. I have tired of apologizing for the plain teaching of Jesus, camouflaging the beauty of meekness, and protecting the egos of the supposed bad-asses. We need to face ourselves and ask why we have been avoiding this virtue for so long.

Conner Locke's avatar

This is a well thought out and written article. Nice work.

Setting the “warhorse” metaphor aside, what images do you think capture gentle/meek well? If I’m teaching on gentleness this fall, what are compelling examples I can point to?

Thanks!

Zachary Wagner's avatar

Great question, Conner.

A few quick thoughts. First, my sense is that the absence of cruelty, harshness, violence, and danger is a big part of gentleness a la praus. So Jesus' description as "gentle" puts him in the category of non-cruel, non-coercive rulers in ancient conceptuality. He is not a king who's going to threaten you with violence or torture to make you obey. Rather, he is one who is gentle, whom little children can approach, and who does not lash out or fight back when he is arrested. He does not come into Jerusalem with an army at his back, but on a donkey. His disposition towards Peter and the soldiers arresting him is a textbook example of his meekness.

Whatever we can say about his cleansing of the temple, it's fair to say (linguistically) that he was not acting especially "meek" in that episode. That doesn't mean he's sinning, of course. But no one in the ancient world would give cleansing the temple as an example of Jesus praus-ness, it seems to me. (And that's exactly where the re-definition goes wrong. When people say things like "meekness means being willing to get violent when necessary." It simply doesn't.)

I also think the animal examples aren't terrible as far as sermon/teaching illustrations. But make sure to include the sheep, hare, cows, and fish examples alongside the lion/horse ones. Some of us are gentle by temperament/disposition, some of us must *learn* to be gentle. Just like some animals are non-dangerous by nature and others must be tamed in order to become safe/useful for humans.

Ryan Boyer's avatar

Solid work. Grateful for those like you making straight what is slightly warped in the hopes of my making Christ's name great.

Zachary Wagner's avatar

Thank you, Ryan!

Brendon Thaler's avatar

the pun “my sense is that the usage of praos/praus is relatively stable” really got me.

love your conclusion that being gentle may imply the restraint of power but does not require it. a gentle dove doesn’t restrict itself, but is not necessarily more or less gentle than a gentle horse.

I do think the offensive nature of the beatitudes should end the interpretive gymnastics from the start. in no way should we expect the beatitudes to tell us “those who are secretly macho and optimize their lives win the world”

Grant Skelton's avatar

Our men's Bible study once discussed the meaning of the word "praus." I'd heard the warhorse definition since around the time you highlighted (early-mid 00's). John Eldridge's works were highly popular then. And nobody said this right out loud in the open. But there was this sense that if you didn't bow hunt or go kayaking every weekend, you were not, strictly speaking, a man. You see the same ethic among men who post photos of themselves loading or cleaning rifles when their daughters get married or engaged. I get the humor, but there's something more going on there.

I live in the South. We don't want to be meek. We want "from my cold dead hands."

But Jesus' cold dead hands held no weapons. And they were only cold and dead for 3 days.

Whitney Lane's avatar

Excellent article but I was really hoping for more mojo dojo casa house jokes

Zachary Wagner's avatar

I had originally planned an entire postscript section highlighting some of the best (worst) examples of AI-art on this... but the article was already too long. So, instead Ken just got the single shout out in the image caption.

Hannah Rowe's avatar

the irony of evangelicalism is that it preaches transformation: once i was lost, now i am found; i was an addict, now i am free; these drastic changes, yet, at the end of the day, the brain always chooses the path of least resistance. there is a tendency to find ways to make gentle into violent, selflessness into self preservation, and giving up power into using power “for good”.

G. Murray's avatar

Excellent article!

TD Craig's avatar

A good article, thanks. However, I must say that the comment about Jordan Peterson "[teaching] young men to become self-controlled monsters" is completely unnecessary and wrong to the point of absurdity. You may not like Jordan, but I'd say the main thing he promotes - and promotes very well - is personal responsibility. I'd also say that his interest in the Bible has been very very influential in driving people towards Christianity and the scriptures. Which, regardless of what you think about him and his motivations, cannot be a bad thing. "Who is not against us is for us" and all that. Regards, Tom

Zachary Wagner's avatar

Hi Tom. Thanks for the comment. I’m alluding to a specific well-known quote from Peterson. See this video, for example:

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/NBwd9OACHtk

That being said, I have decidedly mixed fillings about Peterson. The revision of “blessed are the meek” I mention in this article is a place where I had one of my most negative reactions to something he said. But I have lots of good things to say about him as well, and I positively quote him multiple times in my recent book for Christian men. The interest in scripture, the genuine concern for young men, the pushback against some mainstream political and cultural excesses –– all good to great stuff. Although I confess as a biblical scholar I often find his interpretive instincts pretty wild and fanciful.

I can also see your point about the section in my article you quoted being rhetorically too sharp and imprecise as a description of Peterson’s broader project. That’s probably a fair critique of that concluding paragraph in particular.

Thanks for engaging and all the best.

TD Craig's avatar

Thanks for your nuanced and understanding response, Zachary. That's very heartening. God bless. T

Graeme's Musings's avatar

A tour de force of greek nerdy things, great meme references, and generous but firm analysis towards such a pressing issue for the biblical masculinity crowd. Would be very interested in your thoughts on Miller’s book whenever it drops!!

Zachary Wagner's avatar

Lot’s going on, but I’ve definitely thought about giving it a read when it comes out!

Bill Folliard's avatar

Bless are the flexible those who can adapt not rigged

Marc Sims's avatar

Wow, great work, Zach.

Zane Paxton's avatar

I appreciate your insight. I've heard this teaching on meekness often.

Also, I just finished *Men of Virtue*, where you also touch on this a bit. I think your voice at this time as it relates to our interpretation of the virtues of Christ and the New Testament teaching is really important and helpful.

Thanks brother.

Zachary Wagner's avatar

Thanks for reading and for the kind words, Zane!

Landon Kepler's avatar

Great read! Thank you for sharing your research!

I had a quick question- with "gentle/meek" being paired with "humble/lowly" in Matthew 11:29, did you find any modern "spins" or interpretations for the Greek word for "humble", similarly to meek? Thanks!

Zachary Wagner's avatar

Hey Landon! Glad to see you on here.

I can’t think of anything on the Greek for humble off the top of my head. My hunch is that “meek” tends to make our modern sensibilities more uncomfortable than “humble.”

Also, @Stefani McDade just put something out on humility here on substack. (As well as a longer article in CT.)

John Luongo's avatar

Words mean things, thank you for posting.

Hans Stein's avatar

Thanks for bringing this up with that much thought and consideration.

About a year ago I came to similar conclusions like you did. I looked into Homeric, Aristotelian, and Septuagint usage of the word, into the Hebrew correspondents, and into its (and their) etymology.

I came to appreciate the meaning gentle as a secondary one. I found the ability and readiness to respond adequately as the rimary root of the meaning of the word and its usage.

I had not considered it in the context of water and wind, though, and can only assume it might have come into usage for these inanimate elements in the sense of them not being ruly but so that one can reasonably deal with them (and perhaps πραυσ was appliied meraphorically, anthropophorically, perhaps even theophorically (as expressions of divine kindness and moderation in the force exhibited.)

Daniel L. Bacon's avatar

Well written! Now that your public-facing book is out, I think we need an academic book (or series of books) on masculinity. I think the deeper we look, the weaker the images we use for what it means to be a man become. My three watchwords that attach well to institutions (my whole deal) and to masculinity are safety, legitimacy and provision. If we get these wrong, we consistently veer into coercion, abuse and every evil thing.

Zachary Wagner's avatar

No sure I’m ready to jump in on a thoroughly academic treatment myself, but would love to see someone should!

Daniel L. Bacon's avatar

There is the danger of creating an expedient definition of manhood that misses moral reality but, I think, in acknowledging the danger, exploring and dispelling the images we have inherited as well as giving new images that reflect Christ from a strong academic background would be beneficial in a "beating swords into ploughshares" kind of way. Might not be you or me but also, why not?